Wednesday 16 February 2022

Results: Sudoku Design Competition

Here's what you've all been waiting for dearest reader, the big reveal!

Firstly, in a completely randomly generated order, here are your (mostly) esteemed and highly talented authors.  I will be in touch over the next few days about the best way to send over the prizes.

Entry A - 0403 came courtesy of Yunus Emre Büyükkale
Entry B - 3233 came courtesy of Tom Collyer (yes, that use of the word "mostly" is there for a reason)
Entry C - 4235 came courtesy of Anuraag Sahay
Entry D - 4438 came courtesy of Jiri Hrdina
Entry E - 5308 came courtesy of Sinchai Rungsangrattanakul
Entry F - 5617 came courtesy of Yoshi Baroshi
Entry G - 6071 came courtesy of Kumaresan R
Entry H - 6283 came courtesy of Gareth Moore
Entry I - 7408 came courtesy of Florian Wortmann
Entry J - 7704 came courtesy of tamz29
Entry K - 9133 came courtesy of Sam Cappleman-Lynes
Entry L - 9158 came courtesy of Jack Lance

[I will edit in a link to a permanent page on this blog to showcase the entries in all their glory, as well as update the PDF.  For now the puzzles can be found:]
I have to say that I went to great lengths to draw up entries as soon I received them to anonymise them and leave until after the closing date, so that I had the best chance of not knowing whose puzzle I was solving as I was going through.  The original idea with 3 picks for me was to roughly group into an easy, medium and hard puzzle, but it didn't quite work out that way in the end.  The first three £25 prizes go to:
  • Entry D - Jiri Hrdina
I thought this was a wonderfully smooth-solving easy puzzle, setting up the obvious hidden pairs in boxes 2, 4, 6 and 8.  These boxes together with box 5 then resolve themselves leaving the corners of the puzzle to be mopped up via some more hidden single.  The sort of highly polished easy puzzle I really appreciate!
  • Entry H - Gareth Moore
I thought this puzzle moved away from an easy level in a very pleasing way, nicely setting up a naked triple half-way through the solve; this was definitely something that set this puzzle apart for me.  

But don't just take my word for it, one very experienced sudoku solver thought that:
H - clearly a favourite. It has a nice solving path, not too easy / not ridiculously hard. ... It would be a good puzzle for the WSC finals or something.
  • Entry L - Jack Lance
Last but certainly not least, as soon as I saw entry L I knew I had a winner on my hands.  The symmetry of this puzzle is absolutely stunning with consecutive pairs arranged in Battenberg formation around the grid, attached to another consecutive pair for good measure.  However what I find most pleasing about the symmetry is that it doesn't fall into the pastiched trap of a Gurth's Theorem situation where you only get to solve half (or even a quarter) of a puzzle.  Crucially with this puzzle different given digits in the grid are not rotational symmetric from other given digits, which breaks the symmetry and ensures the puzzle maintains an interesting, albeit easier solve.  Absolutely beautiful - this is the single puzzle from the set that I wish I had written and in my eyes is now *the* definitive puzzle for this layout.  For whatever that is worth :-)

Finally, the last £25 went down to the public vote.  My previous post announced that I would be disregarding votes from the authors themselves, but in the end this made no difference to the overall winner.  Which is:
  • Entry G - Kumaresan R
Interestingly my dearest readers plumped for one of the Extra Hard puzzles, which i think neatly wraps up the set of prizes (I should add I had picked my favourites before I counted the votes - in theory an entry could have one two prizes).  It must be said Extra Hard in this case comes with a bit of a health warning - you can use a uniqueness technique to turn this puzzle into a much smoother solve, however knowing that some solvers prefer not to use uniqueness if they can help it, this was how I felt I had to rate the puzzle.

The author had this to say about the puzzle: 
Actually it is not hard but an advance technique is involved. Without this technique unique rectangle can be used to complete the puzzle.
Whilst another solver said:
The puzzle I preferred requires a very unusual way of uniqueness, which once found solves the puzzle. Not sure for the 10/10 rating for difficulty since it was an easy spot, but surely 10/10 of cleverness!
Narrowly losing out in the public vote (regardless of whether author votes were taken into account or not) were entries H and F.  We've already discussed entry H, but entry F was the other Extra Hard entry from the set, and perhaps demonstrates that there is something of an appetite for more difficult puzzles.

That's it for now - congratulations to all the participants and especially the 4 winners!  I'll probably look to do some more of these fixed layout competitions with other puzzle style in the future, as I think it went down well with both those who submitted a puzzle as well as those who voted on them.  

Tuesday 15 February 2022

Puzzle design competition: results soon

This will be the penultimate post regarding the puzzle design competition. I have decided my top 3 and will be republishing the puzzles with credit over the next couple of days.  I hope you are all looking forward to finally being able to put names to puzzles!

I had fewer votes (10) than entries (12), which I find very curious - I’d like to hear what factors might have been holding people back, even if it’s just speculation.  To those who did vote, thank you very much for participating and leaving your comments, I am glad that you enjoyed this idea.

Some of the 10 votes were from entrants, which I had assumed wouldn’t really matter given I was expecting far more votes than entries, however before tallying up the votes it seems like the only sensible thing to do is to disregard author votes. I can’t see how an individual vote for oneself would not be significant in these circumstances, and given not every author voted there is clear unfairness here in my eyes. 

Saturday 12 February 2022

Public vote closes soon

A friendly reminder to all my dearest readers that the public vote for your favourite entries from the puzzle design competition is closing soon - 23:59 GMT on Monday 14th February. 

I don’t have all that many votes right now so it’s be good to change this over the next couple of days to see if we can settle on a clear winner. 

I hope everyone has been enjoying the puzzles so far!

Friday 4 February 2022

Puzzle Design Competition - Public Vote

Hi everyone,

In case you haven't already seen, I have published the anonymised entries of the Sudoku Fixed Layout Design Competition.  Thanks once again to each of the authors who contributed a puzzle.

The puzzles can be found:
Please note that I haven't asked the authors whether they are happy to provide links to online solving tools, so please take this into consideration before transposing the puzzles and sharing.

As a reminder, I will be awarding 3 x £25 prizes to my person favourites.  The fourth £25 prize will be awarded to the winner of the public vote.

In order to vote, you need to select your own 3 favourite entries and order them in preference.  Your first preference will score 5 points, your second will score 3 points, and your 3rd will score 1 point.  At the end I'll add up the points and whoever has the most will win.


To ensure that people only vote once, the form requires you to be logged in to google.  If this is a concern to you, please leave a comment and I'll see if there's another way that you're able to cast a vote.

Closing date for votes will be: 23.59pm GMT on Monday 14th February.

Tuesday 1 February 2022

Puzzle Design Competition - Anonymised Entries

I am pleased to announce there were a total of 12 entries to the Sudoku Fixed Layout Design Competition.  Thank you very much to everyone who submitted an entry, I am honoured that each of you took the time to participate and I am super excited to get solving and judging what I am sure are going to be a truly extraordinary set of puzzles!

I am in a bit of a rush at the time of the initial post - expect this post to updated, probably with a PDF attachment for your printing convenience.  Please note that I haven't asked the authors whether they are happy to provide links to online solving tools, so please take this into consideration before transposing the puzzles and sharing.

UPDATE: difficulty ratings have been added to the post below, and I have also put together a PDF file.  Please note the difficulty ratings are based on my initial solves - a sample of 1 is not usually great for the purposes of testing so do take these with a pinch of a salt.  It is fair to say that the two entries rated at 10 / 10 are significantly more difficult than the rest of the set however!

PDF of entries

Expect a further post in the next couple of days with the voting form and corresponding deadline (which will be in at least a week's time), but in the meantime I thought all my dearest readers would be very keen to get solving as well.

Entries have been anonymised using four random digits as a reference.  I will further update this page with a rough indication of difficult a bit later; for now I will add that, based on the authors' self-assessments, the difficult levels within the collection range from easy through to very difficult.

The last thing to say is that I have run these puzzles through a computer checker to verify they solve uniquely only *after* I have redrawn into a standard format, so this should mean that there are no transposition errors below.  If not, please let me know in the comments.

Contact Form

Name

Email *

Message *