As much as I’d like to go on about a rocking American band of the 70’s, I think I’d better Keep It Simple, Stupid. Especially in light of recent puzzle-writing dickhead errors on my part. So what could be more simple than a 10×10 Akari?
Well: I haven’t posted the rules before (competent use of the mouse in a leftward direction should help you here); and 10×10 Akari are usually lame. This one isn’t. Enjoy!
#091 Akari – rated mediumAll puzzles © Tom Collyer 2009-10
Nice puzzle. That’s quite the subtle break-in.ReplyDelete
Oh man, multiple bulb pairs. You know that’s my favorite kind of step.ReplyDelete
There are only so many ways that a 10×10 akari can be non-lame – you can try stuff with a slightly denser packing of the grid with black squares, but generally you need more room than 10×10 normally allows you. Anyway, hopefully it provides fun for those solvers who haven’t seen lots of akari.ReplyDelete
It’s a shame there are only two orthogonal directions on paper/screen to play around with bulb pairs. After you do something like the botsu baku nikoli.com puzzle by juno there doesn’t seem to be many obvious choices as to where else you might push the boundaries of the logic. Although again the later Guten puzzle in the Botsu Baku is very good too.
By nikoli’s standards, this is a Hard or an Extra.ReplyDelete
Also, I concur with what MellowMelon said.
Please note: the link to the Akari rules on your blog’s sidebar is broken.ReplyDelete
Ta – it’s fixed now :)ReplyDelete
Nice puzzle! I wouldn’t go as far as calling it a Nikoli Extra kind of hard, but I really enjoyed the initial break-in, quite unusual.ReplyDelete
Not sure if it’s a good place to ask this question, but would you guys mind discussing the mechanics of solving akari on paper?
I have no trouble with most puzzles, but being used to nikoli’s application makes it sort of hard for me to solve akaris this way. See, the trouble is
that I feel like I need 3 kinds of marks: (a) bulbs (b) non-bulbs (c) lighted space. Very often (b) = (c) but obviously it’s not always the case. I am
using circles for (a) and slashes (”/”) for (b) and I’m keeping track of (c) in my head. This is because I am using this circle/slash combo in most
geometric puzzles (nurikabe, tapa, battleships, coral, etc.) and I can do it relatively fast. If I’m adding another symbol, it makes speed solving harder
because it’s harder to distinguish between a larger number of symbols (also the marking itself becomes harder). On the other hand, I sometimes
don’t see (c) correctly and that can lead to some ugly misreads. What system are you using?
I really enjoyed this, thanks! Didn’t think it was that hard – once the breakin was established, the rest of the puzzle fell pretty hard: I’ve definitely seen a lot harder (tho maybe not 10×10)ReplyDelete
Taking into account all the the comments and making an average, the wisdom of crowds probably agrees this was a medium ;)ReplyDelete